Why Were Ghost Stories Once a Christmas Tradition?

The Lantern Keeper • November 15, 2026

Christmas in Williamsburg seems made for stories.


Candles glow behind old windows. Fires burn in hearths. Winter darkness settles over streets that have been traveled for centuries.


Today, ghosts are more likely to make us think of Halloween.


But frightening stories haven't always belonged to October.


For generations, the dark days surrounding Christmas were also a time for stories of ghosts, witches and things that couldn't easily be explained.


And that tradition wasn't entirely foreign to colonial Virginia.

Christmas in Colonial Virginia


Christmas in eighteenth-century Virginia looked very different from the holiday we know today.


There were no strings of electric lights, and many traditions we now consider essential to Christmas came much later. In Anglican communities such as Williamsburg, however, Christmas could mean church, large meals, visiting, dancing, music and plenty of celebration.


And there was storytelling.


Colonial Williamsburg's historical research points to eighteenth-century Christmas entertainment that included traditional tales of ghosts, witches, hobgoblins, fairies and conjurers.


Imagine hearing one of those stories without a television glowing in the next room.


Only a fire.


A candle.


And darkness outside the window.

Why Winter Was Perfect for Ghost Stories


There's a reason supernatural stories fit the season so well.


December brought some of the longest nights of the year. Before electric lighting, darkness was a much greater part of everyday life.


Families and visitors gathered indoors, and storytelling provided entertainment that required nothing more than a willing audience and a good imagination.


The setting did the rest.


A strange noise outside. A shadow beyond the firelight. An old story about someone who died years before.


Winter could make a ghost story feel remarkably close.

Then Came Charles Dickens


The tradition didn't disappear when the colonial era ended.


In Britain, Christmas ghost stories became especially popular during the nineteenth century. Then, in 1843, Charles Dickens published A Christmas Carol.


Scrooge's encounters with Jacob Marley and the spirits of Christmas helped make the supernatural Christmas story famous around the world.


Dickens didn't invent the tradition. He helped carry an older winter custom into a new age.


And more than 180 years later, we're still telling his ghost story every Christmas.


Christmas in Williamsburg Today


Modern Christmas in Williamsburg combines history with traditions that developed long after the colonial period.


Today's familiar candlelit windows, elaborate natural decorations and Grand Illumination create a beautiful holiday atmosphere, but not everything visitors see is a literal recreation of an eighteenth-century Williamsburg Christmas. Colonial Williamsburg itself distinguishes between documented colonial customs and traditions developed during the restoration era.


But walk those streets on a cold December evening and something much older still feels perfectly at home.


Old buildings.


Dark windows.


Flickering light.


And stories.


Maybe Ghosts Never Left Christmas


Halloween may have claimed the ghost in modern America, but Christmas never completely let it go.


We still watch A Christmas Carol. We still tell stories beside fireplaces. And we still find something irresistible about an old house on a dark winter night.


In Williamsburg, where centuries of history surround you, that connection seems especially fitting.


Christmas doesn't have to be frightening.


But after the candles are lit and the streets grow quiet...


there's always room for one more ghost story.

Moonlit mist over a still river at dawn, with silhouetted trees and a glowing reflection on the water.
By The Lantern Keeper • November 1, 2026
Discover the true story of Grace Sherwood, Virginia’s legendary Witch of Pungo, her 1706 trial by water, and the history behind the enduring legend.
Crowd gathered at a lit night market, with warm lights, buildings, and a full moon overhead
By The Lantern Keeper • October 15, 2026
Discover what happens when a Williamsburg ghost tour becomes a hands-on paranormal investigation with real ghost-hunting equipment after dark.
Warmly lit brick mansion at night with glowing windows, a central path, and a moonlit sky above.
By The Lantern Keeper • October 1, 2026
Explore the history and haunted reputation of Williamsburg's Peyton Randolph House, where nearly 300 years of history, mystery and legend meet.
By Mr. Pirate • March 24, 2022
It was a stormy and very cold night when me and Petey got knocked off course as we were sailing through the water in the way the ice ship. The ice ship is a gigantic floating iceberg which plows over and crushes anything in its path, including your friends Petey and Mr. Pirate. The wind was blowing very strong and causing our ship to rock and float of course. We tried to control the ship as best we could, yet to no avail. We just kept getting closer and closer to the ice ship. I could see our path was heading directly in front of the ice ship, when I heard a large foghorn honking at us! I had heard a story of an Australian Sheppard named Nan Nook who was said to help pirates in distress. I thought it was nothing more than a story, however I wondered could there be some truth to this story. I sure hope so, because me and Petey really could use some help. I again heard a loud foghorn and then I heard a loud bark and a voice say “I am Nan Nook the fearless and I am here to help you!” When I heard this, I was overcome with a feeling of complete and utter relief for I knew all was going to be okay. It seemed as if Nan Nook has a vessel of his own. It was a tow barge with a tow hook. Nan Nook swung over the hook, but it got caught on the ice ship! A feeling of great fear took over me and Petey and we thought all was lost. Just then out fear grew to its peak, my best friend Nan Nook the fearless dashed from the deck of his vessel, jumped out grabbed the cable and pulled it to release the hook from the ice ship. As the hook broke loose from the ice, the cable started to pull me, Petey and the ship to safety. Our path to safety was accomplished by our hero Nan Nook the Fearless. It made me realize that Nan Nook is a true hero for with no concern for himself and his safety he saved mine and Petey’s lives. When we were pulled completely out of the way of the ice ship, Nan Nook unhooked the tow and released our vessel from his. He came over onto our ship and we were able to thank him for saving us and the ship. He told me his real home was among the Eskimos and he was saved by them as a puppy. They were the ones who gave him his name Nan Nook of the North. The name Nan Nook means polar bear in Eskimo. He also told me that his official title is Captain Nook (similar to Captain Hook) yet he is called Nan Nook by all his friends. I told him that me and Petey wanted to be his friends from this night on and would appreciate it if he thought us as such. Now this is the way me and Petey met Nan Nook the fearless and became best friends with him. As we said goodbye to him, we could not help but feel we were blessed by our encounter with Captain Nook for we made a very special friend and the Pirate waters would be much safer and less lonely knowing there is a fearless sea dog named Nan Nook watching our back when all seems hopeless and helpless.
By Mr. Pirate • February 25, 2022
It all started one eve as Mr. Pirate was walking through the dense brush looking for Billie Bob the Pirate's treasure. Me had a treasure map. You see, Billie Bob's treasure be buried under the x on me map which I got from him before he died aboard me ship Mr. Billie bob was a mere tadpole when I first met him and we had always dreamed of being pirates as we both grew up together we decided to join the queen Anne's war as privateers as many of the young men were. We were helping the British crown by capturing and robbing the Spanish ships in the queen's name. It was great we were performing the acts of pirates all in the name of the crown and had no fears of being punished for it. We had amassed quite a bit of treasure in the four years we had served in the British navy . The war came to an end and the British won the war. The war was over and the crown had realized they had too many privateers working for them. They had to let many of us go from their employment. The men they had let go had turned to being pirates to make a living. The only thing that now, as a pirate, you were able to be persecuted for your acts. The British crown would no longer protect you, and you would stand trial for your crimes. The punishment for being a pirate was usually death by hanging! The pirates including myself would find an island, and pick a place to bury their treasure, then after making a precise map would then later return for their riches. It was wise to hide your treasure instead of keeping it on you, for if you were caught by the British Navy they boarded your ship and would bring you up on charges. If you had no treasure, they had nothing to charge you with. Many pirates buried their treasure and for no one to ever find. Such as Blackbeard himself. This pirate is said to have buried the treasure of the isles of The Carolinas. The map I had was very easy to follow, but the terrain had changed and the vegetation was thick, for it has been four years or better since anyone had been here. This was one of the problems the pirates had. I did me best to determine where the exact spot of the buried treasure was. As I was walking through the dense vines I realized me and men were not alone. I heard a voice say, "Captain Vaughn, I believe we are not alone!" Then I know my suspicions were true. I looked up into the palm trees and saw a red feathered parrot looking back at me. Little did I know at the time that this bird was going to save me and my men's lives! I shouted out to Captain Vaugh and when I did that crazy parrot repeated me and I heard the captain say "come on men, let's get out of here and back to the ship, we are outnumbered!" That crazy parrot landed on my arm and I said, " What is your name?" He said " Petey the repeat parrot". I said thank you for helping us out and I told him of the treasure we were looking for. He said he might be able to help by flying over the island and looking for the X. I told Petey if he could do this, that he could stay with me as long as he would like. The next thing I know, Petey was flying high above us and in less than an hour he found the X that marked the spot! I had my men dig and sure enough they found Mr. Billy Boys treasure. We loaded the treasure and Petey decided to go with us. I realized I got two treasures that day, but the one called Petey was the most valuable. Now he has been with me for about 6 years. I am very fortunate because I believe I have made a friend for life. He can stay as long as he wants to, and I believe he has made my life happier and more exciting. ​